Owner & Investor Questions
Detailed answers to the most common questions about residential property management for rental property owners.
Our Services & Pricing
-
What is your management philosophy?Our management philosophy is a full-service approach to leasing and property management in which our team manages all day-to-day leasing and operational decisions, with clearly defined authority and owner involvement only when necessary.
-
How long have you been in business?
The owner of Gaylord Property Group has been active in the residential property management industry since 2006. Our experience is built on nearly two decades of service, best practices, and refined management systems. We are focused on integrity, competency, and value.
-
How much do you charge for leasing?
Our leasing fee for long-term tenant placement is one month’s rent.
-
How much do you charge for management?
Our management fee for long-term leases is 8% of the monthly rent collected.
-
How much do you charge for leasing and managing short-term rentals?
Our fee for short-term reservations is 18% of the total rent collected, which includes both leasing and management.
-
Can I negotiate your fees?
No. To maintain a consistently high quality of service, our fees are non-negotiable. Managing properties across multiple locations requires specific, standardized processes to deliver results effectively. Negotiating fees creates operational friction and prevents us from providing the level of service we are committed to for every property and owner.
-
What does your leasing service include?
-
Property Rental Report
-
Professional Photography Coordination
-
Advertising & Listing Syndication
-
Lead Management
-
Showing Coordination
-
Full Tenant Screening
-
Lease Preparation & Execution
-
Utility Transfer Coordination
-
Documented Move-In Inspection
-
-
What does your management service include?
-
Rent Collection
-
Tenant Communication
-
Maintenance Coordination
-
Professional Vendor Network
-
Lease Renewals
-
Rental Accounting & 1099 Reporting
-
Move-Out Coordination
-
Security Deposit Processing
-
Legal Compliance
-
-
Why do you require professional photos?
Professional photography directly impacts listing performance. High-quality photos increase showings, reduce vacancy, and often lead to higher rental rates. It is one of the highest ROI decisions an owner can make for their rental property.
-
Why do you require professional cleaning?
Cleanliness strongly influences first impressions, competitive interest among applicants, and ultimately applicant quality. A professionally cleaned home shows better, reduces objections during showings, and signals that the property is professionally managed. Make-ready cleaning is typically an owner expense prior to leasing and a tenant expense after move-out.
-
Do you handle short-term rentals?
Yes and no. We do not manage nightly or weekly vacation rentals. We manage short-term rentals with a minimum one-month lease term. However, we prefer avoiding lease terms shorter than three months. We have found this is the best approach to maximizing net income by securing high-value bookings while reducing turnover costs, minimizing wear and tear, and avoiding the opportunity cost of missing longer-duration reservations with greater revenue potential. Rare exceptions do apply.
-
What is the difference between short-term and long-term rentals?
Short-term rentals operate like hospitality businesses with higher turnover, bundled utilities, full furnishing requirements, and resort tax compliance. In Florida, short-term leases are generally defined as lease terms under six months. Rental rates, taxes, and fees are often paid in full before occupancy.
Long-term rentals are lease terms longer than six months, have lower turnover, and generally provide more predictable income. Rent is typically paid monthly for long-term leases, and utilities are the tenant’s responsibility.
-
Do short-term rentals make more money?
Short-term rentals sometimes produce higher gross revenue, but not always higher net income. They typically involve increased operating costs, occupancy variability, furnishing expenses, and ongoing management demands. The answer is very property- and location-specific.
-
How often do you communicate with me?
We provide weekly activity reports for long-term rentals during vacancy. Each report includes the total number of inquiries, completed showings, and applications submitted, along with our assessment and professional recommendations to position your property competitively.
You will receive detailed notifications whenever your property is leased, renewed, or when a lease has ended.
You will also be notified each time incoming funds are processed through your account, accompanied by an updated property statement.
Additionally, we communicate with you anytime a maintenance expense is anticipated to exceed our discretionary spending limit and request approval before proceeding.
Each year, we provide an owner year-end letter outlining overall market dynamics, achievements from the prior year, and expectations for the upcoming year.
-
How do you get paid?
Our fees are deducted from the funds collected through your property account. For long-term rentals, the placement fee is due on the lease start date and deducted from the initial prepaid funds, while the monthly management fee is deducted each time rent is collected. For short-term rentals, we are paid on the reservation start date, with the fee deducted from the total proceeds. If a specific fee or expense exceeds the funds collected for your property, the balance is settled using your property reserve or an owner contribution.
-
Do I need to hire a property manager?
That depends on your availability, experience, and desired level of involvement. Self-management can save on management fees but requires you to personally handle advertising, incoming calls, texts, and emails, tenant screening, finding and managing vendors, making repair decisions, coordinating maintenance, and all tenant communication. Many owners choose professional management to reduce stress, reclaim their time, and minimize the legal and financial risks associated with rental ownership.
-
How do I compare property management companies?
Property management companies are not all the same. Scope of services, fee structures, technology, and operational quality vary widely. When comparing firms, we recommend focusing on three key areas:
What’s Included: Ask the company to define exactly what they handle. Are they a full-service firm managing the entire cycle from marketing to move-out, or a hybrid service with limited responsibilities? It is often more important to understand what is not included than what is.
Total Annual Cost: Look beyond the “headline” management fee. Inquire about additional owner fees and tenant-facing fees that might negatively affect rental demand or your bottom line.
Alignment of Incentives: Consider whether the fee structure feels transactional or creates a true partnership. A successful long-term relationship requires a management partner whose goals are aligned with your success.
The right fit depends on the experience you want as an owner and the results you expect for your property. Asking these questions upfront can prevent surprises and ensure your interests are protected.
-
Why should we list with you?
You should list with us if you want a full-service experience and believe in providing a well-maintained property. You value the highest probability of consistent cash flow without the headaches of day-to-day involvement. We operate on the principle that when property management is performed with integrity, both the resident and the landlord benefit.
Leasing & Tenant Screening
-
Is my property ready to rent?
A rent-ready property is vacant, professionally clean, fully functional, safe, and compliant with Florida habitability standards. All major systems and appliances should work properly, the home should show well in photos and tours, and there should be no deferred maintenance that would deter qualified applicants.
-
How much will my property rent for?
Your property will rent for what the current market supports based on location, condition, and competing inventory. Online estimates and ownership costs do not determine rental value. We analyze recent leased properties and current competing listings to establish a price that minimizes vacancy and protects your ROI.
-
How long does it take to lease my property?
Most well-priced, rent-ready properties in Florida lease within 30 to 60 days. Homes that are overpriced, poorly presented, or not fully prepared often take significantly longer. Seasonal demand, overall condition, and pricing relative to current competition all influence timing.
-
Is the Zillow rent estimate accurate?
Zillow rent estimates are often unreliable because they rely heavily on listing data rather than verified leased results. In seasonal markets like Florida, these estimates can be especially inaccurate. It is worth noting that Zillow’s own reliance on its internal pricing algorithms led to the failure of the "Zillow Offers" iBuyer program, which resulted in the company losing over $880 million and shutting down the division entirely in 2021.
Accurate pricing requires human oversight, current leased comparables, active competition analysis, and local market experience, not just an algorithm.
-
Should we accept pets?
It is estimated that over 70% of Florida renters have pets. Restricting pets entirely significantly reduces your applicant pool and can increase vacancy time. For owners who allow pets, we enforce the pet guidelines you approve, including what types of pets are allowed, how many are permitted, and any additional restrictions. We collect a one-time pet fee, and the security deposit extends to any damage caused by the pet.
-
Where do you advertise and how do you show my rental property?
We advertise on all major online rental platforms, including Zillow, Realtor.com, Apartments.com, and Redfin. We use a proven follow-up and scheduling process to quickly respond to all incoming phone calls, text messages, and emails. Most vacant homes are shown using secure self-showings with identity verification, while our team monitors market activity and follows up with prospects to convert showings into applications.
We do not use Craigslist, Facebook, Nextdoor, VRBO, or Airbnb.
-
How do you screen tenants?
We screen tenants using reputable third-party screening providers that review credit, criminal history, income, and rental history. We also verify landlord references and apply objective debt-to-income criteria established in the listing agreement. Consistent screening is the foundation of strong tenancy.
-
Can I be involved in selecting and approving the tenant?
No. Tenant criteria are established upfront, outlined in your listing agreement, and applied consistently to remain compliant with fair housing laws. Applicants who meet the approved criteria are accepted. Most owners prefer this structured approach because it removes emotion, reduces liability risk, and increases conversion rates through efficiency.
-
Do I have to pay you if I find my own tenant?
Yes. Our agreement is exclusive, and most online rental platforms prohibit duplicate listings. All rental inquiries must be directed to us. This ensures consistent communication and a controlled leasing process. By managing all inquiries, we are able to deliver the experience you have hired us for.
Management & Maintenance
-
Do I pay management fee if the property is vacant?
No. Our management fee is based on rent collected. If the property is vacant and no rent is received, no monthly management fee is charged.
-
Who pays for repairs and maintenance?
Routine maintenance is the owner’s responsibility. If a tenant causes damage, we pursue reimbursement from the tenant or their security deposit. We coordinate all repairs through licensed and insured vendors to ensure the work is completed professionally and your liability remains protected.
-
How do you select and vet vendors?
We work exclusively with properly licensed and insured vendors where required. Selection is based on experience, references, reliability, communication, and consistent pricing. Using independent third-party vendors helps eliminate conflicts of interest and ensures work is completed professionally at competitive market rates.
-
Will you call me before doing maintenance on my property?
No. For repairs that exceed our discretionary spending limit, we obtain your approval before any work is started. Routine and minor issues are handled within our management authority to prevent delays and maintain tenant satisfaction. Our approach is structured to preserve owner oversight while ensuring efficient day-to-day operations.
-
Why do you require a property reserve, and what is your discretionary spending limit?
Our discretionary spending limit is $500. We require and maintain a $1,000 owner reserve per property prior to the start of management. This reserve allows us to address maintenance needs promptly, protect the property, and maintain tenant satisfaction. Funds are held in a dedicated account and used only for property-related expenses as they occur. The balance is monitored and replenished as needed through your property account, and any remaining funds are returned to you upon termination of management.
-
Can I do my own property repairs or use my own vendors?
While the property is vacant, owners may complete cleaning, repairs, and other preparation work prior to leasing. Once a tenant occupies the home, all repairs must go through our approved vendor process to ensure proper licensing, insurance coverage, response time, and documentation. This includes repairs related to tenant-caused damage that may be charged against the security deposit. If you have a preferred vendor, we are open to approving them, provided they meet our insurance and licensing requirements.
-
Can I use a home warranty company?
We strongly discourage the use of home warranty companies, as they often create repair delays, coverage limitations, and inconsistent service outcomes that negatively impact tenant experience and operational efficiency. Our priority is to resolve maintenance issues promptly and protect the long-term condition of your property.
-
What if a tenant damages my property?
Damage caused by the tenant, their guests, or pets is the financial responsibility of the tenant and may be covered by the security deposit. While no system can eliminate risk entirely, structured property management helps reduce potential loss. We use thorough screening, detailed lease documentation, and documented move-in inspections to clearly establish the property’s condition. Security deposits provide an initial layer of financial protection, and we actively pursue reimbursement from the tenant when applicable.
-
What if a tenant wants to break the lease?
If a tenant requests to break the lease, we review the circumstances and determine an appropriate course of action. The tenant remains responsible for rent payments, utilities, and all lease obligations unless a formal agreement or approved replacement tenant is secured. Release from the lease occurs only through a documented resolution.
-
What if the tenant stops paying rent?
If a tenant stops paying rent, we follow the legal process by posting the required notices, applying late fees in accordance with the lease, and initiating eviction proceedings if necessary. We handle all communication and coordination to protect your income and minimize stress.
Accounting & Legal Compliance
-
Do you provide the lease agreement?
Yes. We use attorney-prepared lease and reservation agreements designed to be fair and provide strong legal protection for all parties. These agreements include required disclosures such as flood, lead-based paint, electronic notices, and pet addenda where applicable.
-
Do I have to sign an exclusive listing agreement with you?
Yes. For legal clarity and liability protection, we require a written listing agreement that clearly outlines services, responsibilities, and approved tenant criteria. This creates structure, ensures fair housing compliance, and protects both parties. Our agreement is designed to be straightforward and transparent so expectations are clear from the start, and it may be canceled with written notice.
-
What is your cancellation policy and fee?Our agreement is month-to-month with no termination penalties. You may cancel at any time with written notice and at no charge.
-
What property disclosures are required?
Our lease package includes required disclosures such as flood, lead-based paint, electronic notice consent, and pet addenda where applicable. Florida rental properties must also comply with federal fair housing laws, Florida landlord-tenant statutes, habitability standards, and any applicable local regulations.
-
What happens if a hurricane is coming?
We monitor official advisories, communicate preparation guidance to tenants, coordinate hurricane shutter installation when applicable, and conduct post-storm inspections. Tenant safety is the first priority, followed by property protection.
-
Who handles resort tax compliance for short-term rentals?
For properties that may be leased for durations of less than six months, transient rental registration is required. We register your property with the appropriate county and state agencies, collect and remit applicable taxes on your behalf, and maintain the required resort tax records.
-
How is the security deposit amount determined, and who holds it?
Long-term rentals: Security deposits are set based on the rental amount, property condition, and overall applicant strength. Best practice is to keep the deposit within approximately $100 of one month’s rent, but not exactly equal to it. The goal is to provide appropriate protection for the property while remaining competitive and attracting qualified tenants.
Short-term rentals: Damage deposits are set based on property size, furnishing quality, utility structure, and industry norms. Because rent is prepaid, financial credit is less of a concern. Deposits can vary widely but commonly range from one-half month’s rent to one full month’s rent.
All tenant security deposits are held in a compliant trust account in accordance with state regulations.
-
What is the process and timeline for returning a tenant’s security deposit?
After move-out, we perform a detailed inspection and compare the property condition to the documented move-in report. Florida law requires that if no claim is made against the security deposit, it must be returned within 15 days after the tenant vacates. If a claim is made, written notice of intent to impose a claim must be delivered to the tenant within 30 days of move-out, including an itemized explanation.
The tenant then has 15 days to object in writing. Because Florida deposit law is strict, missing the 30-day notice deadline can result in the landlord losing the right to retain any portion of the deposit, even if the damages are valid. Our process is designed to be fully documented, timely, and compliant with Florida landlord-tenant law.
Getting Started
-
How do I get started?
Submit the “List My Property” onboarding form under the Owners and Investors tab on our website. We will review your property information, and one of our Executive Property Managers will contact you.
-
How long does it take to list my rental property?
Once you complete our onboarding form, we schedule and conduct an onboarding inspection. After we receive all required items, most properties go live within 3 to 5 business days. The timeline ultimately depends on how quickly you provide the required items.
-
What do you need from me to list my rental property?
We require a rent-ready property, a signed listing agreement package, a property reserve, and all keys and fobs required for complete access.